Re: composition and inner classes
On 20.12.2006 13:10, gaurav v bagga wrote:
With composition, the part object may belong to only one whole;
further, the parts are usually expected to live and die with the whole.
How to handle this in java, I saw few C++ codes where they handle
deletes of child in destructor, in java should I implement an Inner
Class ???
Nesting of classes and nesting of instances are two completely
orthogonal concepts. You do not need to have a nested class to nest
part instances. Whether or not you create a nested class should be
solely determined by the usage of that class, typically you do this only
for classes that are only used and can only be used inside the
surrounding class.
Basically, if you want to ensure that an instance is to be discarded
with the surrounding instance, you must not leak the object reference of
the part to any client code. However, the question is whether it's
necessary.
Since Java has a completely different object model and memory model than
C++ you cannot easily translate concepts. If you present more details
about the problem you are trying to solve we can come up with
suggestions how to tackle that in Java.
If this is just a theoretical discussion of general concepts then I'd
say formally speaking there is no way to ensure that a part lives no
longer than the whole because of Java's garbage collection; even if you
do not leak the reference of the part to the outside the GC is still
free to collect the whole but leave the part alone. I'd also say that
to me this seems far less of a problem in Java than it might be in C++
exactly because of GC; so you just might not worry too much. :-)
Regards
robert